Wow, is all I have to say. This book took a complete 180. As the story drudged on about his survival, he finally discovered land in his lifeboat. Japanese investigators from the Cargo ship company met Pi there to hear his story and try to find insight as to how the ship sank. Pi told him his story clad full of the tiger, zebra, hyena, orangutan, and all of the other far-fetched happenings on the tiny lifeboat. They shot down his story and told him they wanted to hear the real story. This is big twist ending. Spoiler alert! He began to tell how the zebra was a sailor, the hyena a French cook from the ship, the orangutan his mother, and himself the tiger. It turned into a horrible story of cannibalism, murder, and survival.
In their report, the investigators marked on how they were unable to find the cause of the sinking cargo ship and ended it with a note on how brave and courageous Pi's survival was. Not only had he been at see for 277 days, but he had done it in the company of a Bengal tiger. This just goes to show that even though the story without the animals was more probable and plausible, it was much harder to believe purely for the fact that no one wishes to see humans in that light. No one wishes to think ill of our own kind. Therefore, it was easier to settle on Pi's outrageous, animal-clad story as truth.
I think this story shows a lot about humans and how we are nothing short of barbaric animals when it comes to our own survival. It was a great allusion and an even better story. However, I agree with the investigators; I liked the story with the animals better too.
So, would you pair this one with Lord of the Flies to investigate human nature? I'm not sure I quite understood the plot as you explained it, but it makes me wonder what made this a fantasy text? That is the genre you thought it fit, right? Do you suppose the text has such a slow start because there was some foreshadowing to the end that you could have caught if you hadn't been lulled into this sense of a dull text? I'm kind of curious how the author pulls it all off. What do you think was the power of the writing?
ReplyDeleteIt definitely reminds me of Lord of the Flies except it was a lot more vivid and almost disturbing. The author wrote the human story with such detail it truly showed how barbaric people can be when desperate. I actually looked it up to see what genre it was and it said fantasy. I think it was because of how far-fetched the animal story was. The human story was only about a page long as opposed to the animal story taking up the majority. The beginning does give some insight as he talks about his studies in zoology and Religion/Philosophy. I think this was a major part to keep in mind because the animal story as an allusion towards the human race is a mixture between these three majors. I didn't see too much foreshadowing now that I think about it but it is definitely possible that I overlooked it while trying to get through the beginning. The power of his writing was definitely the detail he used. This let the reader feel like they were there in the lifeboat with Pi. And then to turn that detail completely around and fit in the human story was simply mind-blowing. It made you question absolutely everything you had just read because everything fit so perfectly together.
ReplyDelete